PhotosArchives FA-Q Food Geekfest Colophon

Wednesday, August 3, 2005

Two much

(Potential plot spoilers ahead)

Potter Potter everywhere, but not a kid to shrink
Water water everywhere, but not a drop to drink

I woke up every morning of last week muttering to myself that I would not write a post on Harry Potter ‘cos everyone, their uncle and their uncle’s dog has written about it. And yet here I am. Comments ranging from ‘I am so swept up by Rowling’s world of magic‘ to ‘I don’t know what the big deal was, it was a pretty pedestrian book‘ to ‘I refuse to read anything that is so hyped‘ to ‘woof woof‘ have peppered the blogosphere. But whichever way the wind blows, Potter has found his way into a post on pretty much every blog.

And at the risk of getting publicly lynched by Rowling fans, I still maintain what I said after I finished Book Three — that Rowling’s stories (not necessarily her writing style) are simply put — Lord Of The Rings meets Enid Blyton. A parallel magical world set in a dorm. Tolkien and Blyton fans, please to not kill me. I am oversimplifying just for example’s sake. This is not to say I won’t read Rowling. Yes, the deed has been done. The ubiquitous book has been read, the person who had to die, died, the Half-Blood Prince has been discovered and other such earth-shattering trivialities have been dealt with. And I am also mighty pleased that my guesses about both were on target. And yes, I have a theory about where the seventh Horcrux is. Much joy.

On an unrelated and more serious note — In the aftermath of the Mumbai rains and floods, there are a couple of new collablogs that have sprung into action. Please go visit them and if you can, help. Here’s what one of the blog creators, Peter Griffin (also the person behind the TsunamiHelp blog) has to say —

Almost a thousand people dead in Maharashtra, about half of them from Bombay. Transport screwed, no electricity, no running water, some areas STILL under water a week later.

They haven’t even begun figuring out how many people were injured. Or what the tolls might increase to if the epidemics we all fear do happen. (And that’s likely, if you have sewage mixed with rain water standing thirteen feet deep in some places) They have’t even begun estimating what the losses of property are going to be like. So many have lost everything.

Bombay needs help folks. We can analyse what went wrong later. We can figure out what to do about it later. Right now, Bombay needs help. Bombay’s bloggers (and some friends - the net doesn’t worry about borders) are trying to do their bit, by making sure information is easy to find. Information was one more thing we all didn’t have enough of last week. Not that it’s much better now.

http://mumbaihelp.blogspot.com/ is an effort to put online such critical “for emergencies” information as we can find. We hope to turn this into a permanent site that will act as a Bombay disaster portal.

http://cloudburstmumbai.blogspot.com/ is a collection of news, both from the media as well as stories sent in via email and blog links.

Link to us if you run a site, pass these links around to your friends, send us information, send us stories Cloudburst@googlegroups.com.

Pass the word, people. It’s a small gesture, considering the enormity of what has happened, but we hope it will go a long way.

As they say, too much of anything can be bad — Potter or water.

61 Comments
  1. blogman · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    One Potter movie was enough for me. No more Potter movies and no more Potter books. I don’t think they are engaging enough for an adult.

    About Mumbai .. what a tragedy. Do they do urban planning in India? I’ve always wondered about that seeing the way roads and buildings were built. Now add drainage and sewer systems to that list.

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 2:22 AM

  2. He who Shall Not be Flamed · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    What i am scared of is apathy taking root again. (well, not scared of; i’m pretty sure it will). Come to think of it, thats some food for thought for a blog-post.

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 5:52 AM

  3. Raghu · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    Megha, WHO ARE YOU?
    Are you some kinda blog Diva or what? 106 comments, 94 comments, 72 comments! WOW…

    I love the movie, ‘A walk in the clouds’ and so when I saw your blog title I had to visit you. And when I did, lo behold! I was overwhelmed with the overflowing commentspace.

    The shock is more so, probably, because I am a fresher to the blog world.

    Well, anyway your style of writing is gorgeous. I have linked you to my blog.

    In the meanwhile check out my blog in couple of days for a post on Harry Potter. I am sure you will find it different.

    Bye.

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 7:57 AM

  4. Nandu · Other comments for this name

    Will you please do us the honour of sharing where and what you think the 7th horcrux is? I have an opinion on that too!

    And, thanks for the links on Bombay - I grew up in the city and it has always been and will always be the centre of the universe for me. Hate to see what’s happened to it - hope to see it (and not just the people, but the city itself) bounce back soon.

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 8:35 AM

  5. Devdutt · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    Hmm…yeah…about the 7th horcrux…I’m all ears.

    Prerna’s a Mumbai-wali, so it was very close to home.

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 9:17 AM

  6. Megha · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    [blogman] So which Potter movie did you actually watch? Personally I’ve found that the books cater to an adult audience well, so I have to disagree with you about that. But the movies, especially the first one, was turned too much into a kiddie flick, IMO. It lost the charm and magic that the book had.

    [HWSNBF] The fear, or rather, the inevitability of apathy in turn makes us more indifferent, I think. At least to an extent. Definite food for thought.

    [Raghu] Who am I? Hmm, the eternal question with no answer. But blog diva?! Eeeks no! Don’t go by those comment numbers. That’s just cos we like to indulge in a lot of tangential talk and nonsensical babble around here :) And thank you for the link on your blog. I’ll be sure to check out your blog and I look forward to this ‘different’ Harry Potter post! Glad you stopped by for a visit and hope to see you around more often :)

    [Nandu] Okie, spoiler alert for all other readers. Some Potter-talk coming up next. You have been warned.

    I think the seventh horcrux is in Harry. Dumbledore tells him how horcruxes are mostly stored in inanimate objects, since storing a part of your soul in another being with a soul of their own can be dangerous. Of course V’mort never intended it to be in Harry, but then his killing of Harry’s parents didn’t go exactly as per plan either. Am thinking in the seventh book, Harry will finish off Voldy but will die himself. Total Sherlock finishing off Moriarty style. It also fits with the prophecy. One cannot survive while the other lives, it says. But it doesn’t say both cannot die! :) What’s your take on it?

    While I can’t claim to be *from* Bombay (it is nice to see someone still refer to it as that) entirely, I was born there and grew up there some. So the city will always have a special place in my heart. Hope your family is safe and well.

    [Devdutt] Theory has been elaborated upon in response to Nandu. Pliss to read and offer opinion.

    Hope Prerna’s family are all doing okay.

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 9:32 AM

  7. The Greatest Hokie Ever !! · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    Secular Rights India has an excellent blog piece on apathy and general disdain for life in India

    http://secular-right.blogspot.com/2005/07/cheapening-lives-to-reduce-their-cost.html

    Megha, how come Harry Bhai and Bombay in the same piece ? Any connection I am missing ?

    [blogman] I agree the emphasis on urban planning has been minimal to none, more so in Mumbai, than anywhere else. Not an excuse, but I doubt if any urban system can cope up with 37 inches of rain in one day. I know (from painful experiences) that 6 inches of snow can shut down Washington DC. I remember the plague in Surat and how there was a total urban transformation in Surat after that. Perhaps, we will see a new wave of urban planning inspired Mumbai !! Well, I can hope, can’t i ?

    tsk, tsk, after getting my HP equated to Enid Blyton meets LOTR, I am back to digging through book 6 to see if I can find clues for the seventh book

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 9:49 AM

  8. scorpigle · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    This potter book was most different from others.. me thinks.
    Unlike the other potter’s this one doesn’t have much of Harry’s stand alone heroics. No fighting Voldemort, no fighting any magical cratures.. just plain vincible guy… interesting horocrux guess.. waiting to hear if others have a different opinion.

    [The Greatest Hokie Ever !!]- I agree 37 inches of rain is too much for any urban planning or infrastructure of a city in the world with that kind of a population.. but the no. of lives lost is something to be grieved upon as our inability.

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 10:23 AM

  9. Dharmendra · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    you two much brutus! just read my blog on HP6. like they say, great minds think alike ;)

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 10:45 AM

  10. Megha · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    [Hokie] 6 inches of snow might shut down a Washington DC, but it is the loss of life, as [scorpigle] mentions, that is the most appalling difference. And that, while largely due to 37 inches of rain, also has to do with a city bursting at the seams, with way more people than it can support, methinks.

    No Hari Puttar connection to Bombay. Just Potter and water - two things on my mind this weekend..

    [scorpigle] Very true. Harry’s grown up, more in control of his temper and all that sort of thing. I think Rowling’s, in a way, trying to show that magic can only get you so far. It is what’s inside you that finally makes the difference between ordinary and extraordinary. I guess that’s an important lesson for her teenage fans to learn, since they have to live their lives without the convenient magic wands their make-believe friends have.

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 10:53 AM

  11. Megha · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    [Dharmendra] Aha! Most excellent! GMTA or FSD, one wonders :)

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 10:56 AM

  12. Closet Claustrophobic · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    Call me a prude, but why was there so much snogging in HBP? But I sort of liked it towards the end, all very well set-up for final book.I wonder if Snape will change sides one last time in the final book or is he really on the Dark side?

    But, ya kids these days I am telling you, I wonder if they read Trixie Belden and the like?

    And the clouds do cause much havoc don’t they? :) And I had no idea how bad things were till one of the Bangladeshi’s in my team said, ‘Heard that Bollywood has drowned?!’. And I was like, it can happen to any other city, but not Bombay. Good of you to be posting this.

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 12:20 PM

  13. Harish · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    errr.. Megha, there are only 6 Horcruxes!

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 12:43 PM

  14. Megha · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    [Closet Claustrophobic] Ah, you had a problem with the snogging eh? I had a problem with the romance in general. It was too cheesy. ‘Ginny had a blazing look in her eyes as she rushed over to hug Harry’. Bleh. I had heard from peoples before I read the book, that it picks up pace and gets interesting towards the last quarter, but to be honest, that was my least favorite part. Instead I totally enjoyed the trips down memory lane, courtesy the pensieve. Gives you a better sense of what a bad boy V’mort was and all. And yesh, methinks Snape will change yet again. If Dumbledore trusted him, he has got to have had reasons better than ‘Snape felt guilty for telling Voldy about the prophecy’ and so I’m inclined to trust him, as well.

    Trixie Belden! It has been *aaaages* since I read one of those!

    [Harish] Uff :) I’m counting the soul in Voldy’s body as one of them, hence seven. The ‘something belonging to Ravenclaw or Griffindor‘ horcrux is the one we’re talking about. A friend of mine mentioned that there is an allusion in one of the books that Harry is a descendant of Godric Gryffindor. Is this true? Does anyone remember reading this anyplace? I don’t, but then I cannot remember a book I read last night, so I’m the last person to vouch for this.

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 1:28 PM

  15. aNTi · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    Megha: I have been following Amit Varma’s updates and then the cloudburst blog since it started. I think everyone in Mumbai was lulled into a false complacency these past few years. Other than the transportation system, Mumbai seems to have the infrastructure problems as any other metro in India. It is a rude awakening, but I hope it is an eye-opener for everyone else concerned as much as it was for me.
    Someone told me that the Virar ka Chokra is absconding (i.e. has been out of sight for the last one week) and that should be another lesson for us to make our electoral choices right when we have the chance to. Gaurav Sabnis has a excellent post up trying to see through the “Blame Reliance Energy” campaign by the politicians and it makes a lot of sense….

    Hmmm, me reading HP at the rate of 100 odd pages a night and it was my second night. Suddenly now, I can’t remember anything from the previous book and I think I will stop HP6 now and re-read HP5 again. This two year gap between books is spoiling it for me. Anyways, I won’t get down to reviewing the book or something cos essentially its not targetted at me (though i seem to have enjoyed the previous parts). The target audience is close to a dozen years younger and makes no sense to me trying to analyze a children’s book.

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 1:41 PM

  16. He who Shall Not be Flamed · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    “The fear, or rather, the inevitability of apathy in turn makes us more indifferent, I think.”

    Nice thought, that one…

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 1:54 PM

  17. Nandu · Other comments for this name

    Ok, the horcrux being in Harry is my idea too. The whole deal with the scar and Harry being able to connect with Voldy is because of the fact that a part of Voldy’s soul is in Harry. And remember that the Sorting Hat wants to initially put Harry in Slytherin in Philosophers Stone? That was because of a part of Voldy being in Harry. Else, there can be no reason for the Hat even considering Slytherin, given that Harry’s parents were Gryffindors themselves.

    Dunno about this everyone-dies-Sherlock-Moriarty-types finish though - much as I would like a conclusion to the book set above a roaring waterfall and Ron/Hermione playing the ‘miserable bungler’ narrating the whole situation a la Watson. I am, however, UTTERLY and COMPLETELY convinced that Snape is a good guy and his killing Dumbledore is part of a vast masterplan to win Voldy’s confidence, so that he can help Harry finish off Voldy from the inside. Methinks Harry will figure this out only after bumping Snape off in HPVII….

    Avinash Wadhwan, Harry Potter, Bombay (which is what the city will ALWAYS be called by people who grew up there), Sherlock Holmes, Trixie Belden….Jeez, your blog posts are excellent fodder for nostaliga trips…..:). And I should really start a blog of my own instead of just posting these elaborate comments on other blogs!

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 2:23 PM

  18. Anonymous · Other comments for this name

    The movies are amusing for sure, and very often excellent visually. As for the books, having Narayan, Hemingway, and Mortimer on my to-read list, I’m afraid I just don’t have the time for Harry Potters and Da Vinci’s codes. I’m helped by the fact that the Potter books are made into movies, all of which I’ve enjoyed so far (in 2 hrs instead of the 8-10 it might take me to read them). In the words of Jerry Seinfeld, “you know what I like about the movies - No reading!”

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 2:34 PM

  19. The Greatest Hokie Ever !! · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    Excellent quote by [He who Shall Not be Flamed]

    As I listed in my post, hopefully, Mumbai and other metro cities will arise from their slumber and do something positive about urban planning. [Megha], while Mumbai is bursting at its seams, I am sure if constructive minds are put at the problem, we would be able to find a solution where man and city can both co-exist.

    Coming back to Hari Putar, me thinks that Sirius and Dumbledore both will make a grand return in book 7. They never showed Sirius ka body in Book 5 and mebbe JK Rowling might have seen a Nirupama Roy movie !!! Hope is eternal.

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 4:44 PM

  20. scorpigle · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    [nandu] methinks.. and meagrees.. Snape had nothing else to do.. he couldn’t take on all of them together and with ol Dumby having lost his wand either both of them would have got killed or Snape busted as not being on Tom Riddle’s side [i like the name].. and the sanctity of “unbreakable vow” maintained.

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 5:34 PM

  21. aNTi · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    Umm… me thinks all these plot twists should be left for later discussions. By later, I mean, till just before the last book releases. Some people might just not have gotten their hands on their copies yet and here we go discussing everything from who, why and how someone died.
    This comment section is getting much more descriptive than the actual book.

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 8:58 PM

  22. abberanti · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    J.K. Rowling has an amazing publicity team. The book is awful, but the sensatiolist news she gets has made sure that, of all things, ‘Harry Potter’ gets a place on the alltime list of books to read. Nice blog. Do visit mine.

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 9:42 PM

  23. Sagnik Nandy · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    very unrelated comment but there are people on my blog who are claiming that you post comments in my blog under another name. i just found the whole thing hilarious - so thought of mentioning it here :))

    Wednesday, August 3, 2005 @ 10:32 PM

  24. Megha · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    A general word of caution to all readers - if you are mentioning any potential plot spoilers in your comment, please precede it with a spoiler alert. That way people who aren’t yet done with the book can cautiously skip past your comment and still read the other comments. Thankoo :)

    [aNTi] Yes, I read about Govinda just yesterday. Was catching up on his silliness about the PIL/PRO thing on Gaurav’s blog.

    I completely agree about the two year gap being a bit of a pain. It interrupts the flow. I fortunately have a friend who was reading HP5 while I read HP6, so whenever a character showed up or an incident mentioned that I no clue about, I knew just who to ask :) And I don’t believe the HP books (especially HP5 and HP6) are being written for a child audience anymore. In fact if I read these two books when I was 12-13 I would have been positively frightened. Then again I was an easily-scared kid, so that’s not saying much. But I think Rowling has realized the global audience she has, and she no longer writes only for kids.

    And if you are still reading the book, you definitely should be cautious around this commentspace. I’ll try to give you plot spolier alerts if possible to make life easier for you. How much more to go, btw?

    [He who Shall Not be Flamed] Thank you..

    [Nandu] Ah, yes, I forgot all about the Sorting Hat! Very true that. And I am most glad that my blog makes you write these elaborate comments that in turn make me remember some long-forgotten trivia which I then babble about. At the same time I think starting a blog of your own is a great idea. So why not do both? :)

    [Anonymous] The movies are definitely improving with each successive episode, but I still think the books are better in terms of the visuals. Which again is true of pretty much any book that is made into a movie, I suppose. (Do any exceptions to that rule come to mind?) And I am one of 2.23% of the people who has not yet read the Da Vinci Code. Yes, that is my confession for the day.

    [Hokie] About the quote .. um .. :)

    Yes, I do think that the problem is not beyond hope. And hopefully this will light the necessary fire under the people that need to be woken up. Ultimately, I am sure that Bombay will emerge bigger and stronger out of this. And it will do so much faster than any other metro.

    The cool thing about books involving magic and spirits is that *anyone* can come back alive! Let’s wait and watch :)

    [scorpigle] Hmm, very true. I do believe that Dumby trusted Snape for a darn good reason, even if that reason is not apparent to us. And what’s good for Dumby is good for me :)

    [abberanti] Anything that is this hyped can never live up to the expectations it creates, in my opinion. The books make a decent read, but we’ll never be able to read them unbiasedly. Will be sure to visit your blog. Thanks for dropping by on mine! :)

    [Sagnik] Ooooh, really? I shall be over soon and see the drama for myself. Sounds promising :)

    Thursday, August 4, 2005 @ 12:10 AM

  25. Minal Rahate-Sangekar · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    Megha,
    You are such a bollywood freak and your posts ever entertaining!
    I must agree with Raghu who says you are a blog diva!!

    You seem to score a century everytim you post, atleast a half is in the offing!

    At this rate you mustve overtaken Sachin Tendulkar by now;-)

    Keep the good posts coming

    Thursday, August 4, 2005 @ 1:30 AM

  26. RT · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    LOTR + Enid Blyton = HP.
    Yeah actually true, dorm meets fantasy..And yes, I was able to guess who might have died and the HBP, well Have to read the books before that to understand the reference..:-)
    And about Bbay, the city is still reeling from the downpour and me being part of the troubled victims. The never-say-die spirit is what holds the city together and calamities as this has not done enough to shatter that. Hoping the rain gods have unleashed all their anger and life gets normal.

    Thursday, August 4, 2005 @ 2:16 AM

  27. Prashanth · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    Well I couldn’t help myself… fingers twitching… I just *had* to write a review of Half-Blood Prince. So I did:
    http://myfavouritecouch.blogspot.com/2005/07/not-for-muggles.html

    Interesting theory on the last horcrux… oh well only JKR can clear it up for us.

    Thursday, August 4, 2005 @ 2:58 AM

  28. aNTi · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    [Megha] I did not mean to prod you into that comment about spoilers :(

    No offense meant…to anyone here!

    But ya, after my quota of 100 odd pages yesterday I can’t agree more with the fact that the target audience seems have shifted up! All that talk of snogging!
    Whoa.. and that was a sudden shift, don’t you think? Ek summer vacation mein kya different hotha. Or am I losing track of the story line from HP5!

    Thursday, August 4, 2005 @ 10:12 AM

  29. Saurabh · Other comments for this name

    Hell, you are one helluva writer. Stumbled upon ur blog while pretending to do research in my dingy little lab, and it has made all the “procrastination” as the PhD comics like to call graduate work, worth it.

    Anyway I am a huge HP fan, and formed the exact same theory as you did. And believe it or not, in those exact words. I have been trying to convince a few of my friends of my theory, with the prophecy bit also thrown in, but frankly, they think I am nuts. It’s really great that I can now show them someone who shares my theory:-)

    Thursday, August 4, 2005 @ 11:26 AM

  30. Sriram · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    Haha! I’m not early!! anyways, let’s just say I hate Potter. ME is still recovering from seeing the pictures of devastation at mumbai. Will have a better account of things, since my friend is flying here, from mumbai. so wait for an update. and Grrr…. me will start a fire.. time to do some Voodoo on you for not visiting my blog :D :D.. african dance anyone?

    Thursday, August 4, 2005 @ 4:32 PM

  31. Swathi · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    ur post is like a commercial movie with a message- Potter n water.

    i think i agree with ur theory on how the final book wud turn out to be.

    Friday, August 5, 2005 @ 12:27 AM

  32. Minal Rahate-Sangekar · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    Megha,

    There was a competition on here on one of the FM stations” Bollywood Badshah”. Trivia about Bollywood.

    Just thought about you, you would’ve given the finalists a run for their prizes!

    Friday, August 5, 2005 @ 8:13 AM

  33. loverBoy · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    The heavy rains in Mumbai were indeed a tragedy and a wake up call for us. Its time drainage and sewer systems of metros are properly planned. And response time of the government in emergencies like this are evaluated and improved.

    Megs, LOTR + EB = HP is an insult to Tolkien, Blyton and Rowling combined. LOTR is a legend of such brilliance that it cannot simply be compared with anything. As for Blyton, though his books are great to read, it is totally in a different league. For Blyton’s books are not so dark or adventurous as HP (I cannot argue this statement as I haven’t read Blyton’s full work). Finally, Rowling is great in her own stream. Tell me honestly, hasn’t Rowling made you wish atleast for a second to hold a wand or play quidditch?

    As for your theory of the sixth Horcrux, I liked the idea. Didn’t really thought in that direction. It now looks so obvious!

    Friday, August 5, 2005 @ 8:17 AM

  34. karan · Other comments for this name

    I see that the ‘charm’ of the wizarding world is wasted on some muggles here!
    I think HBP was a super read. Much better than the 5th one, and an excellent setup for the grand finale.

    *SPOILER*
    Exactly my (and a probably millions of others’) thought on the Horocrux. Its gotta be scar we haven’t stopped talking about since day one!
    And Snape is obviously on the good side!
    But the fact that both these things are such straight-forward deductions, it makes me wonder :) Rowling wont’ be able to meet the expectation from HP7 if she thinks like everyone :)
    Someone spread the rumor that its Hermione who dies at the end *gasp* I read the book with a heavy heart and was kinda glad to find out that it was just an evil rumor! Though surely, the end was sad in its own. And [megha], its Prof. Dumbledore for you, not Dumby! ;)

    And hey, all great stories have the good vs. evil theme. Even if HP=LOTR+Blyton, it is no way a lift-off and doesn’t make it any less wonderful.
    MY confession: I haven’t read LOTR. Haven’t seen the movies(coz i wanna read!). Yes, I exist. :)

    [loverBoy] “As for Blyton, though his books”
    She would be offended!
    Funny, but when I read Blyton I somehow always had the image of a male author. Until one day, after having read scores of his books I picked up another one with a lady’s pic on the jacket cover! :)

    Sunday, August 7, 2005 @ 5:07 PM

  35. gvenum · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    I haven’t had a chance to read HP series. As a matter of fact I haven’t had a chance to read anything in my life yet, no wonder I have been delaying my book post though been book tagged by 3 bloggers already. But I love anything that has fantasy.
    I heard such depressing stories from my friends in Mumbai, its quite sad.I will put up the links on my site,not that many visit my blog but it might be of help to some one and would also be a helping hand for all the effort you have put in for this just cause.

    Sunday, August 7, 2005 @ 5:43 PM

  36. loverBoy · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    Oh God! How can I be so dumb? I always thought Blyton is a he. I apologize to Blyton and all her fans!

    Hey [Karan], thanks for opening my eye!

    Sunday, August 7, 2005 @ 11:51 PM

  37. Megha · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    Sorry for the delayed responses to comments. Life has been a tad bit crazy lately.

    [Minal] Aw thank you :) I still prefer not to be a diva of any sort. Somehow my over-fertile imagination conjures up images of a sequinned queen with a tiara to boot furiously writing a blog post, pausing to blow at her freshly painted candy-red fingernails, wave them around airily and go ‘whatevahhhh‘. Scary visual no? And a Bollywood trivia quiz would have been so much fun! Been ages since i’ve participated in one of those :)

    [RT] Glad you agree about the HP = LOTR + Blyton bit. As you can see, i’m getting a bit of flak about it from horrified Rowling fans ;) And it sure is nice to know that the resilience of the city and its people is getting Mumbai back on track. It’s what makes Mumbai the place it is! :)

    [Prashanth] You, me and everybody else has their fingers twitching much like Harry’s scar I suppose :) Glad you dropped by and commented! And nice post!

    [aNTi] Arrey, you did a good thing, so don’t go being sorry for it! The eagerness to talk about the book is huge, so we tend to get a lil carried away, and it is good to be cautious for the sake of others. And yes, the snogging is relentless. Apparently, Harry is no longer a RMB ;)

    [Saurabh] Thank you! It is always gratifying to know that one is contributing generously towards the completion of other people’s Ph.Ds ;) And as you can see, there are many others here who support the theory you and I have, so more power to us! Am glad you stopped by and commented and hope to see you around again! :)

    [Sriram] I visited, I read, I fell off my chair in shock at the serious post you wrote AND I commented. Mission accomplished on all fronts :)

    [Swathi] A commercial movie with a message. Now that can be both a good or a bad thing :) But glad you agree. Lets see how worthwhile our theory is. Another two years to go, I guess!

    [loverBoy] Okay let’s see. Both LOTR and a majority of Blyton’s work was written approximately 60 years ago. So saying that Rowling’s work is a combination of the two, is at most, an insult to Rowling, but certainly not to Tolkien or Blyton. Secondly, Tolkien’s vivid visuals have no comparison and neither are Blyton’s books particularly dark. THIS is exactly why I said Rowling was a combination of both, the implication being that she’s borrowed a little from both places and built upon it. Nopes, I am not calling her a plagiarist. I enjoy Rowling’s writing and her world of fantasy but there are plenty of parallels to Tolkien and Blyton that are hard to miss. At least that’s my opinion and i’m sticking to it :)

    [karan] Arrey! Now when did I say I did not like HBP or HP in general! Hmpfh :) I’ll say one thing though - the general public opinion seems to be that HBP picks up steam in the second half and gets really interesting towards the final one-third. This is an opinion I disagree with. I, on the other hand, found the first two-thirds of the book to be the best. The trips down memory lane courtesy the pensieve were most wonderful. Voldemort was just a generic bad guy who killed a lot of people until now, but getting an idea of his past, and getting a more close-up view of some of his crimes makes him a more formidable villian, in my opinion. It was undoubtedly the best part of the book for me!

    Yeah, I am beginning to wonder if it is as simple as Harry being a horcrux. But then again I did guess the identity of the half-blood prince as well as who dies in HBP accurately (pats herself on the back), so maybe her surprises aren’t that unexpected. And nopes, I wasn’t suggesting that Rowling plagiarized from Blyton or Tolkien. Please see my response to [loverBoy] for more info :)

    Speaking of you existing .. (see, I am not heckling you for having not watched the LOTR movies, I am so nice no?) - Weren’t you supposed to start a blog and post pictures on it from your small town and what not? :)

    [gvenum] Yeah, am well aware of your avoidance of the book tag. I was one of the people who tagged you, remember? :) And thank you for spreading the word about the the links. Every bit of effort goes a long way, so don’t think that it won’t help. And I hope your friends in Mumbai are all doing well now. By the way, nice work on the new design for your blog! I haven’t had a chance to come over and comment, but I just briefly drop in and it looks mucho cool! :)

    Monday, August 8, 2005 @ 12:35 AM

  38. Minal Rahate-Sangekar · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    Megha,
    How about a hindi film tag!That would be fun.

    My childhood pal has come down from States for a few days. Only she & I were total hindi movie buffs and TV buffs!! We could watch TV endlessly much to the frustration of our parents:-)

    Your filmi knowledge is too high to catch up, so I think you are the ideal candidate to start the filmi tag!

    I’m most ashamed at myself for not yet having read Harry Potter though I claim to be a big fan!!I have avoided all posts about Potter, and once I’m done I’ll get in touch with u on the same:-)

    Monday, August 8, 2005 @ 2:09 AM

  39. Megha · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    [Minal] If you haven’t yet read the Potter book, I would advise you to be very careful around the commentspace of this blog cos there are spoilers galore!

    And a Hindi film tag - now that sounds like a fun idea! I wouldn’t want to turn it into the standard boring book tag type of thing though. You know the kinds that are all over the web - What are your top five movies? What movie have you watched the maximum number of times? Those are boring questions. I’m thinking of something with a bit more of a twist. Let me mull over it some more ;)

    Have fun catching up on movies with your pal! And thankoo for the idea! :)

    Monday, August 8, 2005 @ 6:12 PM

  40. He who Shall Not be Flamed · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    hmm. 39 comments. One has come to expect a lot more at this blog.

    Suggested questions for the Hindi film tag:
    a. Last movie watched from the front row of a dingy movie hall.
    b. Last time you’ve put up with a movie just because you’d paid for a ticket
    c. Last movie someone paid you to watch.
    d. Five Ramsay brothers movies you have seen
    e. Five movies whose tickets you bought “Dus ka bees, dus ka bees” style

    Monday, August 8, 2005 @ 11:30 PM

  41. Megha · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    [HWSNBF] Thank you for the crossover to 40. And tsk tsk. You know what they say about expectations and all? (That’s an actual question. I have no clue what they say about expectations, but it seemed like the appropriate thing to say.)

    I likes suggestions vairy much! Here a few more I thought of -

    * Name a movie you have never watched that you wouldn’t admit to in public for fear of being lynched. (You’d be surprised how many people respond with Sholay to this one)

    * Select one from the following list that you had a crush on - Rohan Kapoor, Chunkey Pandey, Ravi Behl, Sudesh Berry or for the men - Shikha Swaroop, Ashwini Bhave, Varsha Usgaonkar, Priyanka.

    Hmm .. the gears are surely turning now! :)

    Tuesday, August 9, 2005 @ 12:11 AM

  42. karan · Other comments for this name

    OMG..one’s gotta be on the alert around you! [:)] First, you try and force on me the idea of a photo blog of my super city. Then, you quite innocently go on to ask about what happenend to my plans of doing so ?!
    Anyways, its all moot: I haven’t got a camera, yet! *sheepish grin*

    you gotta post some more great pics to maintain my inspiration level at the required threshold for a reasonable time…maybe then, I’ll cross over! [:)]

    Tuesday, August 9, 2005 @ 12:27 AM

  43. Minal Rahate-Sangekar · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    Hey Megha,
    I liked the idea of film tag with a twist:-)
    Got me thinking too now;-)
    Interesting, waiting for it to kick-start now:-)

    Tuesday, August 9, 2005 @ 12:54 AM

  44. Minal Rahate-Sangekar · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    I’ve scrolled over the Potter comments! Don’t worry, I shall refrain from reading reviews, comments, posts till I’m done:-))

    Tuesday, August 9, 2005 @ 12:55 AM

  45. He who Shall Not be Flamed · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    For a sec, I thought you were referring to the number of states you have visited when you said “Thanks for the cross-over to 40″. And i was like, muh?

    Does never watching DDLJ count as a serious enough offense?

    Secondly, that choice should be a no-brainer for any male who knows who Shikha Swaroop is. Not for nothing was she Miss India ‘88.

    Tuesday, August 9, 2005 @ 4:05 AM

  46. Megha · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    [karan] I thought the idea to start a blog of your own was always your idea. I was merely being .. supportive :) And since when is that a bad thing? There is no bhalai ka zamaana left anymore, I tell you! Tchah! And get yourself a camera will you? Will post some pictures soon! :)

    [Minal] Will keep you posted .. still in the formative stages as of now ;)

    [HWSNBF] Have half a mind to start calling you [HWHCTSONWDDLJ] instead.

    Some people never sleep it seems. I am certainly seeming like some of those people right now, so I really have no business saying anything, do I? And what a neat lil coincidence that was! You bring the count here to 40 and I come over and gloat about 40.

    Yes, madam was added to the crush-list especially for you, so please to appreciate. I had half a mind to put Somy Ali or some such random babe instead, but relented at the last minute.

    Tuesday, August 9, 2005 @ 4:15 AM

  47. He who Shall Not be Flamed · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    No sarki ones on sleep schedules, pliss. Geek lifestyle and all that.

    Eternal thanks for adding madam to the list. I would have wasted away to nothingness if Somy Ali’s name had been there instead of hers. :)

    Tuesday, August 9, 2005 @ 4:39 AM

  48. Megha · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    Excuses-shmexcuses. But wokay. Although methinks sarki-ness should be allowed when it is subtlely masked in self-deprecation. Or not so subtlely, in this case.

    Speaking of madam, I had the hankering to listen to ‘mera laung gavacha‘ today but couldn’t find online source. Pointers? Also, who sang the song? A friend was asking if it was Parvati Khan.

    Tuesday, August 9, 2005 @ 4:48 AM

  49. He who Shall Not be Flamed · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    Here is a link
    Unfortunately its a remix, not the original. You are in luck. I found this site the other day after i’d posted about madam.

    Tuesday, August 9, 2005 @ 4:58 AM

  50. Megha · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    [HWSNBF] Much thankoos. I shall listen to it as a lullaby and follow it up with nightmares of reincarnating snakes. G’night :)

    Tuesday, August 9, 2005 @ 5:07 AM

  51. VC · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    Wow! 50 this time also. I think it is safe to say u r the Rahul Dravid of the IndUS Blogosphere.

    Tuesday, August 9, 2005 @ 2:24 PM

  52. Megha · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    [VC] Thank you :) Credit this time largely goes to Shikha Swaroop. In the last post, the laurels belonged to Avi-Wadh, and the one before that Shilpa Shetty. Is it just me, or is there a disturbing trend here? ;)

    Tuesday, August 9, 2005 @ 5:03 PM

  53. VC · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    I wouldn’t consider this too disturbing a trend. To use the cricket analogy again, Even Rahul Dravid has to rely on tailenders sometimes to score runs.

    Tuesday, August 9, 2005 @ 6:38 PM

  54. Megha · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    [VC] Hmm, interesting analogy that! In some cases, the very post relies on them, so that’s taking things to an all new level I suppose. But your tail-enders theory applies nicely to this post. Thank you for making me feel better :)

    Tuesday, August 9, 2005 @ 8:04 PM

  55. gvenum · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    I found few audio clips of the song Mera Laung Gawacha sung by Noor Jahan and Mussarat Nazeer. But the audio quality is quite bad (atleast on my computer). I can promise you won’t have nightmares of reincarnating snakes but just Sridevi singing title song of “Chandini”…now that can’t be bad:)

    http://www.gupistan.com/gs/printthread.php?t=172387

    Tuesday, August 9, 2005 @ 10:33 PM

  56. KJ · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    hi megha (DIVA),

    am just back from bombay. it was such a mess. i had never thot that bombay wud face such a situation. But believe me, people sprang back to normal life as soon as they can. Normal as in meaning “blaming the govt for anything & everything that goes wrong”.

    Wednesday, August 10, 2005 @ 12:45 AM

  57. Megha · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    [gvenum] Thanks for the links! I was really hoping to get my hands on the Naagmani/Anu Malik version though. But thank you for looking! :)

    [KJ] Good to have you back. I hope all your family is safe and fine? It’s nice to know the city has bounced back!

    Friday, August 19, 2005 @ 7:05 PM

  58. akash · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL


    I think the seventh
    horcrux is in Harry.

    Just wondering, for a horcrux to be created isn’t it necessary to kill the person. And we all know that Harry is still alive. Just following the arguement that Lord V . wanted to store the last horcrux in Harry.

    Wednesday, August 31, 2005 @ 3:20 AM

  59. Pallavi · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    yeah and I have yet to read it… I would rather advertise Water than Potter :)

    Wednesday, September 7, 2005 @ 3:51 AM

  60. Megha · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    Late response that will likely not be read.

    [akash] A horcrux can also be stored inside a live being too, case in point - Nagini. *Someone* needs to be killed for a horcrux to be created, but the person it is being stored in doesn’t have to die. Plus as we all know, something went wrong in Voldy’s plans of killing Harry and his parents, so i’m sure he didn’t WANT to or intend to store it in Harry. It just happened by accident. At least that’s my theory anyway :)

    [Pallavi] Take your time. The next book isn’t coming out until 2 years from now, so you have loads of time to catch up :)

    Friday, September 16, 2005 @ 12:35 PM

  61. Fragrance · Other comments for this name · Other comments for this URL

    Great one !! Keep it up

    Tuesday, March 28, 2006 @ 7:43 AM

Post a Comment

See a preview of your comment here